A stranger comes to your door. He makes you an offer. You have 24 hours to decide whether to push a button inside a box. If you push the button, someone you do not know will die and you will receive one million dollars. What would you do? What would you think or feel? What would you feel if you pushed the button? Too bad this film isn't interested in these moral dilemmas.
Norma and Arthur Lewis (Cameron Diaz, BEING JOHN MALKOVICH, & James Marsden, X-MEN) are given this proposition from Arlington Steward (Frank Langella, FROST/NIXON), a mysterious man with a severally burned face. The Lewises are living above their means. They're sending their son Walter (Sam Oz Stone) to the private school Norma teaches at, but they can't really afford it. Just like they can't afford the sports car Arthur drives. He's spending his astronaut paycheck before NASA even approves him.
With these problems floating over their heads, they contemplate the ramifications of pushing the button. But not enough time. Director/writer Richard Kelly (DONNIE DARKO) is far more interested in the mystery of where the box came from. This plot heavy thriller borrows from many sci-fi flicks, especially INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS. As the plot gets more complicated, the less we care about Norma and Arthur.
Too many of the plot elements that had potential are just red herrings. Norma has a deformed foot, which gives her a unique perspective on Mr. Steward's scarred face. This is supposed to pay off in an emotional scene that ultimately amounts to nothing. So does Arthur's obsession with Mars. So many of the elements seem like padding. I've not read the Richard Matheson short story on which the film is based, but I'm sure it had to be expanded on to make a feature film. Because this is the case, what seems poignant in a short tight story seems anticlimactic after nearly two hours of sci-fi mumbo jumbo.
So often when a story stops working, elements that might have worked in a better told story become comical. Overly menacing extras elicit chuckles instead of chills. Awe inspiring science elicits eye rolls. Ominous music makes everything seem so overwrought, especially when the ending leads to nothing new. At one point Arthur takes the box apart to see how it works. He finds nothing inside. I know how he feels.