With his latest, Mike Judge makes strides forward as a director, but steps backwards as a writer. In both OFFICE SPACE and IDIOCRACY, there was a rawness to the framing and the pacing, but the invention of the screenplay made up for it. In this comedy, Judge makes the material slick and flow easily, but has less original things to say and less thematic control.
Joel (Jason Bateman, JUNO) is the hard-working owner of an extract factory. General Mills is interested in buying his company and his partner Brian (J.K. Simmons, JUNO) is eager to never see the troublesome employees again. While business is booming, Joel's personal life is in a huge rut. If he doesn't get home by eight o'clock, his wife Suzie (Kristen Wiig, WHIP IT) put on the sweatpants and he gets nothing. His eye begins to wander when they hire a new temp, the gorgeous Cindy (Mila Kunis, FORGETTING SARAH MARSHALL). His drugged out friend Dean (Ben Affleck, MALLRATS) suggests Joel hire a gigolo to seduce his wife so that he'll have a free pass to sleep with Cindy. The problem is Cindy is a con artist who has shacked up with Joel's injured employee Step (Clifton Collins Jr., CAPOTE) in order to convince the worker to sue for millions.
Judge has a lot going on in this film. There's the factory politics. Mary (Beth Grant, DONNIE DARKO) constantly refuses to work when she thinks the Mexican workers aren't doing their share. Rory (T.J. Miller, CLOVERFIELD) is a metal head who screws up all the time. Step took pride in his work until the accident. Brian can't remember any of their names. Joel loves the extract business, but no one else cares about it like he does. This is where his problems with his wife come in. Then you have his relationship with Dean, who is the kind of friend that would be your enemy if he had any one else to confide in. Also in the mix is the neighbor Nathan (David Koechner, THANKS FOR SMOKING), one of those pushy neighbors that make you hide in your house.
If all these pieces seem like a lot to deal with in 92 minutes you'd be right. Events build on each other humorously. Brad the gigolo (Dustin Milligan, FINAL DESTINATION 3) and his interactions with Joel and Suzie are some of the high points. The drug interludes with Dean are the low points. The various pieces are weaved together smoothly, but in the end they don't amount to much. Joel and Suzie's relationship is too thinly developed to care about. The look at factory life is intriguing, but Joel's desire to sell right from the start doesn't really mesh with his "love" for the extract business. Nathan and Dean seem like sitcom observations rather than real characters. Dean especially seems like a plot device rather than Joel's true friend.
EXTRACT's title is fitting. Judge's observant eye extracts characters from real life. But sometimes parts get boiled down too much. If the sitcom antics are the artificial flavoring added, they overwhelm the recipe. Judge keeps adding ingredients and watered down characters, making the final product a bland stew. In one taste, some good ingredients stand out like Bateman. The next taste will be sour like many of the awkward plot resolutions. Like an extract, the film might taste like the real thing, but something about it tastes fake at the same time.