Combustion 4 Review

Tara DiLullo descends into the seedy underworld of Sin City to see how the filmmakers ripped the images from the graphic novel page and plastered them onto the silver screen.
Posted In | Magazines: VFXWorld

As a teacher of digital effects and animation at an art school that focuses entirely on Adobe’s After Effects, I have always been intrigued by the Combustion toolset from Autodesk (formerly Discreet under the new Autodesk Media and Ent. division). I have followed the software since its first release in 2000 and was excited to see the newest revision, Combustion 4, released recently for a price of $995. Autodesk/Discreet has been known to create some of the industry’s most compelling and powerful toolsets and their digital compositor/animator/painter/editor software package is no different. This new release focuses on both new tools and revisions to older tools and will satisfy users from casual to hardcore.

Starting off with some brand new functionality is the Gbuffer builder. Traditionally users could impart additional information from 3ds max into renders via the RPF (Rich Pixel Format). Now using the Gbuffer builder, Combustion users can generate simple or complex Gbuffer information from within the software package itself using the new Gbuffer builder Operator. Vfx such as 3D glow, 3D fog, 3D depth of field are now accessible and functional thanks to newly generated Gbuffer information. This in-package solution is one of the concepts that Discreet always got right with this software series. It is really interesting how two companies (Autodesk/Discreet and Adobe) could make such similar products but implement them in such different ways. Combustion users have always enjoyed the in-program, keyboard free style of the software’s interface. Specifically, Combustion is moving further and further into the direction of an all-inclusive, one-stop-shop piece of software. Combustion also has a wonderful workflow that they have designed so that the artist never (OK, almost never) has to move his/her hands to the keyboard. All parameters have a click-n-slide adjustment function (which Adobe has since incorporated into After Effects) and all numerical values can either be slid up and down or double clicked and entered using the super-cool popup calculator.

There is now a powerful Diamond Keyer included in Combustion 4’s keying suite, which is a relative to the keying solutions available in Discreet’s high end, award-winning Flame visual effects system. The Diamond Keyer (Figure 1) provides extremely fast and highly customizable keying functionality. With just a single click, most keying jobs will be complete. To do this, just click one of the nine presets listed in the keyer (R, G, B, C, M, Y, highlight, midtone and shadow), and you will find that your keying is either done or very close. Next, direct your attention to the color diamond and use the twp editable diamonds to manipulate your color groups to create a very clean key. This color palette and corresponding diamond selections are zoom-able and pan-able to make it easy to make very precise keys.

Forunately, this is all viewable (as are all edits) while in RAM playback mode. This in and of itself is something that After Effects aficionados will drool over since they will be used to the pause/edit/RAM render/RAM preview workflow that they are accustomed to.







Comments


As a user of Combustion since version 2.1 I can say without hesitation that this is by far the best upgrade, yet. I started off using After Effects a few years back, but was always frustrated with the tiny font used in the interface and the crowding effect of floating windows everywhere. I keep it around because of certain plug-ins that work well within AE. One of them was DVMatte Pro, and excellent keyer for DV work. But, I recently heard that the Diamond Keyer in Combustion 4 has algorithms designed to handle DV keying. Suffice it to say, I tried the Diamond Keyer on some of my own home video greenscreen shots taken with a Mini DV camera. The results? Impressive. I don't think Combustion is just giving AE a run for its money. I think it's running it out the door. I never understood those who claimed they found Combustion's workflow/interface to be confusing. Unless you find comfort in tiny viewpanels, tiny font, and floating windows you have to shove around to see what you're doing half the time. As it was pointed out in the review, you barely have to touch the keyboard while working in Combustion. And when you want to change settings? Click on the appropriate module button, and the controls change to those of that module. How much simpler can it get? How much quicker can a workflow get? Don't get me wrong. I hope After Effects is always around. Although I find it annoying that Adobe took out features in v6.0 that were in v5.5, then put them back in v6.5 only to charge you extra for putting them back in. Nice slight of hand guys. But, Combustion needs the competition. After Effects is still improving. But, Combustion is better, IMHO. And has been since v3.
Todd Groves (not verified) | Thu, 04/21/2005 - 00:00 | Permalink

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.