Dinosaurs Never See It Coming: Are the Gatekeepers Clueless?
It happened a year or so later. I had left
the studio and, more importantly, I had seen Flash (which has become
the de facto standard for downloadable 2D animation on the
Web). Like a mystic in the desert, I saw The Vision: the World Wide
Web would come to dominate the media in what others have called
(I'm too conservative to do so) the greatest advance in communication
since Gutenberg. Or at least it would change the more mundane concern
closer to my heart: the distribution of what we call "TV animation"
to the mass of consumers.
Which brings us to disintermediation.
Disintermediation is the process whereby an intermediary is removed
from an economic equation. In other words, how the middleman is
squeezed out of a transaction, whether it be a tangible purchase
(downloading software on the Net directly from the publisher, instead
of going to a store to buy it) or the provision of a service (reading
this magazine on the Net, once again directly from the publisher).
Elsewhere on the Web you can find discussions of disintermediation
with regard to the effect it has on the freer flow of information,
which is the aspect of the Web that brings from media mavens the
analogy with Gutenberg. The concern here is more with how it will
change the patterns of commerce that have come to dominate our industry
over the last 50 years.
Disintermediation as a major economic force was first documented
25 years ago or so, when the process of corporate finance borrowing
moved away from the banks (middlemen). Prior to then, banks would
hold excess institutional funds, paying a lower interest rate to
the owner of the funds than the banks received from the eventual
borrower. (It's called the spread.) Borrowers found they could raise
money at a lower cost by directly selling debt obligations (corporate
notes) to the very same institutions, while the institutions found
they could receive a higher return on their funds. These transactions
eliminated the intermediary (the bank), and thereby avoided the
cost of the spread to both the borrower and lender. The process
revolutionized the banking industry, and in some ways led to all
the banking crises since, as banks no longer had (or have) the highest
quality loan customers and therefore have been playing in riskier
arenas, like loans to Russia and investments in Internet start-ups.
In TV, the middlemen are broadcasters, cable
and broadcast networks, and syndicators, and a process, not unlike
what the banks suffered, is now squeezing them out. In the old days
we called them "gatekeepers" (among other names not to
be used in a family publication), and they controlled the medium
while skimming the cream off the top. Simply put, they paid a set
license fee to the producer (who did at least keep other rights)
and derived all the income from the transmission of the shows. With
the fragmentation of the audience since the early `80s, which has
been noted
previously in Animation World Magazine, audience size
has diminished to the point that most straight license fee deals
are no longer feasible for producers. As a result, the gatekeepers
have found it harder and harder to source shows in the former fashion. Many of our friendly vertically integrated
media empires have spent the last decade doing their best to avoid
the negative results of disintermediation. The standard corporate
answer to this squeeze is vertical integration, whereby a media
conglomerate controls all the steps from creation through final
delivery. Time Warner is perhaps the best example: one division
creates the show, another distributes it, yet another exhibits it,
and still another delivers the show to the consumer through a cable
into the house. Simple solution - an adaptation of the old model.
And while it's working for the time being, it may not work so well
in the future. With the advent of Flash, and other means
of delivering animation over the Web, the traditional form of distribution
is under attack. The number of sites offering animation entertainment
already outnumber the cable and broadcast networks, and it is only
a matter of time before their audience size grows exponentially
and speeds the erosion of the "old media" dominance. Aiding
this trend is the oft noted fact that youthful audiences are early
adopters of new media. On the Net, the highest penetration figures
are for the age group under 24 (over 80% of teens regularly use
the Net), and TV claims that Net users were previously "light
TV users" does little to alter the reality that there is a
seismic shift in entertainment patterns.

























Post new comment