Winsor McCay’s Animation Lesson Number One, 1919

Karl Cohen has found a copy of Winsor McCay's long lost lesson on animation. Read about what it contains and what these tidbits mean to animation's history.

Text Fig. 13
A Bird in Flight
Drawing showing how Mr. McCay utilizes his split system in picturing a bird in flight for animation.

The most important technical knowledge he shares with us is what he calls his split system. He says “it is my own invention.” His system was used to carefully lay out and time an entire sequence. He began by laying out the path of the movement for the sequence on page number 0. The finished guide was then used under other drawings that were made on separate pieces of paper placed one at a time over the guide. This gave him the correct position for each drawing.

McCay tells us he began by drawing the first and last images of the sequence (extremes, he doesn’t mention using key drawings), and then his center or middle drawing. He calls the center image the split drawing. By the 1930s this was known as the breakdown drawing or the passing position. If he were animating a sequence that was going to end in an odd number of drawings then he would have an even number of drawings on either side of his split and his split would be equal distance from either extreme. He then drew his subject midway between his split and an extreme, and continued drawing in this manner until the sequence was finished. McCay’s discussion of drawing for animation ends at this point (Richard WilliamsThe Animator’s Survival Kit barely begins at this point) and he moves on to discuss his career, achievements and the future of animation.

The Real Basics
One of the charms of this publication is how primitive and unsophisticated it is. Most of the basics presented to students today are not discussed. There is no mention of squash and stretch, yet he used it for humorous effect in his first work Little Nemo, which premiered April 8, 1911 according to John Canemaker’s research. While he does present us with a ball in motion, there is no acceleration and deceleration. His drawing guides or charts show his movements spaced between the extreme positions.

In his discussion of timing he explains that when Gertie is lying on her side he wanted to show her breathing. He realized it doesn’t take as long for us to inhale as it does to exhale, but he couldn’t get his timing right by using his wristwatch. He says that by watching the second hand on a large clock he was able to figure out the correct timing of the sequence accurately. The movement of Gertie breathing while lying on her side is subtle, natural looking and the sequence is quite charming.

Text Fig. 7
Animated Action on the Flitter Pad
You will find that you can get Additional Effects by Using Red and Blue Marks parallel with the Black.







Comments


I am very interested in following up on a relationship between the work of Winsor McCay and that of Emile Cohl. I would like to know if there is any proof out there of McCay coming into contact with Cohl's work, and the possibility of this affecting both W.M's cartooning and animation work.

Ryan Standfest (not verified) | Thu, 02/04/2010 - 21:11 | Permalink
Excellent article and reply.
Miron Murcury (not verified) | Sun, 03/09/2003 - 01:00 | Permalink
Thank you to Heather Kenyon to have given me the card of AWN in Annecy last year. Your site is very interesting. I have some comments on the activity of Winsor McCay concerning the beginning of animated cartoons between 1914 and 1919. Emile Cohl (1857-1938) has drawn the first animated cartoon in 1908. The title of the film was "Fantasmagorie" in France, "Metamorphosis" in U.S.A.. It has been released in the Théâtre du Gymnase in Paris on August 17. Many others animation films were produced by him at the end of 1908 and during the following years (many are lost, but I have the titles, dates, length, etc.). So I have been rather surprised when I read some years ago, at the beginning of the film "Gertie the Dinosaur" : "This is the first animated cartoon in the world". It seems that Emile Cohl had already had a knowledge of this notice as I have found in his archives a note expressing his surprise. I have also in the documents left by Emile Cohl some flipbooks dating about 1908/1910. Emile Cohl has also built the first drawing table (or animation table) at the end of 1908, as it was absolutely necessary for his job. I have presented the relative photos and documents in a conference at the Domitor Congress in Montreal last June. When he worked in Fort-Lee, N.Y., between 1912 and 1914, Emile Cohl had the occasion to meet George McManus, who appears later on in a film by McCay on Gertie. Maybe McCay has learnt several things from Emile Cohl ... I apologize for my English, but I hope the readers will understand everything.
COURTET-COHL Pierre (not verified) | Fri, 11/15/2002 - 01:00 | Permalink

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.