Mind Your Business: You Will Lose All the Rights to Your Own Art

Mark Simon is mad as hell and, in this month's "Mind Your Business," he tells you why you should be too.
Posted In | Magazines: AnimationWorld
Mark Simon.
Mark Simon

As you know, I usually handle the subjects in my articles with a sense of humor. That is not the case this month. I find nothing funny about the new Orphan Works legislation that is before Congress.

In fact, it PISSES ME OFF!

As an artist, you have to read this article or you could lose everything you've ever created!

An Orphaned Work is any creative work of art where the artist or copyright owner has released their copyright, whether on purpose, by passage of time, or by lack of proper registration. In the same way that an orphaned child loses the protection of his or her parents, your creative work can become an orphan for others to use without your permission.

If you don't like to read long articles, you will miss incredibly important information that will affect the rest of your career as an artist. You should at least skip to the end to find the link for a fantastic interview with the Illustrators' Partnership about how you are about to lose ownership of your own artwork.

Currently, you don't have to register your artwork to own the copyright. You own a copyright as soon as you create something. International law also supports this. Right now, registration allows you to sue for damages, in addition to fair value.

What makes me so MAD about this new legislation is that it legalizes THEFT! The only people who benefit from this are those who want to make use of our creative works without paying for them and large companies who will run the new private copyright registries.

These registries are companies that you would be forced to pay in order to register every single image, photo, sketch or creative work.

It is currently against international law to coerce people to register their work for copyright because there are so many inherent problems with it. But because big business can push through laws in the United States, our country is about to break with the rest of the world, again, and take your rights away.

With the tens of millions of photos and pieces of artwork created each year, the bounty for forcing everyone to pay a registration fee would be enormous. We lose our rights and our creations, and someone else makes money at our expense.

This includes every sketch, painting, photo, sculpture, drawing, video, song and every other type of creative endeavor. All of it is at risk!

If the Orphan Works legislation passes, you and I and all creatives will lose virtually all the rights to not only our future work but to everything we've created over the past 34 years, unless we register it with the new, untested and privately run (by the friends and cronies of the U.S. government) registries. Even then, there is no guarantee that someone wishing to steal your personal creations won't successfully call your work an orphan work, and then legally use it for free.

In short, if Congress passes this law, YOU WILL LOSE THE RIGHT TO MAKE MONEY FROM YOUR OWN CREATIONS!

Why is this allowed to happen? APATHY and MONEY.

Artists have apathy and corporations have money.

We need to be heard in order to protect our incomes, our creations and our careers. GET OFF YOUR ASS!

That means writing letters to our congressmen and representatives. That means voicing your opinion about how we need copyright protection, as we've had since 1976, that protects everything we create from the moment we create it. This is the case around the world.

However, an Orphan Works bill is also in the works in Europe. I was speaking recently with Roger Dean, the famed artist of the Yes album covers, and he is greatly concerned with what will happen if Orphan Works bills become law.

"This will devastate the livelihood of artists, photographers and designers in a number of ways," Dean says. "That at the behest of a few hugely rich corporations who got rich by selling art that they played no part in the making of, the U.S. and U.K. governments are changing the copyright laws to protect the infringer instead of the creator. This is unjust, culturally destructive and commercial lunacy. This will not just hurt millions of artists around the world.

"On the other side of the coin, what argument will a U.S. court have with a Chinese company that insists it did its research in China and found nothing? If the cost of this is onerous for a U.S.-based artist, what will it be like for artists and small businesses in emergent economies?"

If an artist whose work is as famous as Roger Dean's is concerned with this legislation, it should be of great concern for all of us.

The people, associations and companies behind the Orphan Works bill state that orphaned works have no value. If that were true, no one would want them. However, these same companies DO WANT your work, they just don't want to pay for it. If someone wants something, IT HAS VALUE. It's pretty simple.

Some major art and photography associations, or I should say, the managers of the associations, support this bill. The reason they support it is that they will operate some of the registries and stand to make a lot of money. Some have already been given millions of dollars by the Library of Congress. Follow the money and you will see why some groups support this bill of legalized theft of everything you have ever created.







Comments


Mark, have you researched the actual bill itself or have the number? Do you have any handy links to read about the bill itself? I appreciate your bringing this to light, but I think it's important to go right to the source. I can Google as well as anyone, but it would be helpful to have easy access to government docs on the proposed legislation. Before I write to anyone in Congress, I want to know the facts as well as opinions. I encourage every artist to do the same. Research carefully before acting. If a million artists fire off letters about a bill without supporting facts, we will all look like uninformed zealots and it will lessen our effectiveness in petitioning future legislation. I'm just advocating rational thought over panicky action. I intend to do a lot of research on this outside of the Partnership. Let's be SMART artists and copyright holders.
David Billings (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
That makes me mad as hell, theres nothing right about this bill, NOTHING.
(not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
Sir, you write for a magazine. If you have something to say, that's fine, but leave the forum-standard emotionalism to message boards. We're mature people - some of us out here are, anyway, and we are capable of understanding what you're saying without use of caps and the like. That kind of sensationalism isn't professional, and surely that's not what they're paying you to portray.
A K (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
This is BS. I could end up on welfare with this! This is what I do for a living! How can our senators/governors/everyone-in-charge think that screwing all of us over is okay? We need to pay our bills too! That, and everything I create is mine! I pulled all-nighters, I have calluses on my hands, I cut my fingers up with a knife, I welded it! It's mine! And damn anyone who tries to claim it!
Alise Matula (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
I would like more information. Would you post the specific bill that is being debated right now? I'm looking through the Congressional Record and not finding anything.
Dennis S (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
Every time I turn around, I find myself wondering how long is it going to take for the American people to take a stand against this government we've created! I am only one person, but I will create a petition, collect as many signatures as possible and forward them to the "powers that be." Thank you for bring this to my attention. Susie Porter
Susie Porter (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
How about writing a template letter for everyone interested to send their local Congressman and Senators. They count and keep track of opinions but don't actually read them. This is the best way to put your thoughts into action.
Joyce Lieberman (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
I see a lot of "OMG! Protect yourselves!" in this article but not a lot of factual detail. What is the Orphaned Art act? What are the details about it? When is it being proposed? Any legislation has steps and criteria...so what are they? I want to know exactly what this proposes, verbatim. Otherwise, all your article is is a sensational article meant to rev people up.
Wendy (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
un... believable!!! how can those F0©k!n a$$h0les do this!?!? who would ever get to such an insane idea in the first place!!?? u really must be heartless then!! gee... u really took the words outta my mouth... what more is there to say? i'd like to send those bastards an e-mail... but .. what do i say? it's not like i completely understand what u say since im Dutch, am only 14 AND have dyslexia Dx damn money addicted a$$es...
Lydia ---- (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink
You know this really makes me wonder about remaining an American. I have served my country and so has over 90% of the males in my family tree, and to think that MY government can and will do this makes me ashamed of fighting for a group of people that are to LAZY and STUPID to get off there asses and challange our own government. It is OUR RIGHT AND DUTY TO DO SO!!! WHEN OUR GOVERNMENT IS NO LONGER ACTING IN THE PEOPLES FAVOR, WE HAVE THE RIGHT AND AGAIN DUTY TO DISMISS IT AND START A NEW ONE. DOWN WITH BUSH, DOWN WITH THIS GOVERNMENT WE NEED TO BURN IT TO THE GROUND!!! THIS IS OUR COUNTRY, WE THE PEOPLE. WE TELL THEM WHAT TO DO THEY WORK FOR US REMEMBER!!!! SO LETS DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT !!!!!
Eric Dryden (not verified) | Mon, 04/14/2008 - 00:00 | Permalink

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.