Dr. Toon: Handicapping the Oscars: Best Animated Feature

Dr. Toon acts the part of a Vegas bookie and casts the odds for each short listed film’s chances in the big Oscar race.
Posted In | Magazines: AnimationWorld | Columns: Dr. Toon

“There’s no business like show business” as it goes, and at the time of this writing the World Series of show biz, the Oscar Awards, is being planned. Ever since the Oscars began to include animated features as a category, yearly speculation about potential winners has been as intense as that concerning live-action features. There are early frontrunners, holiday spectaculars slipping in under the wire, and long shots that never broke a weekend record but still display enough artistic merit to put up a fight for the gilded statuette. The rivalries between some of the studios represented are as well publicized as the films themselves, as are the technological battles between 2D and 3D animation. It may be that the quest for Best Animated Feature is one of the most fascinating aspects of this year’s Oscars, and with the cost of producing and promoting animated films in 2004, one of the most pivotal for the future of animated features.

Eleven films are currently under consideration as this year’s title contenders. All of them will have been released by the end of November, and it is possible to actually begin handicapping the race for the Oscar. There will be some tight competition and last-minute politicking, to be sure, but part of the fun for animation fans is trying to guess what might transpire amidst the glitzy lights of L.A. Thus, my odds for Oscar night, in descending order of likelihood, to include the final three that will actually compete for the penultimate prize.

Clifford’s Really Big Movie (1,000 - 1) Warner Bros. Cliff’s cute and he commands kiddie creed, but unless the judging committee is made up of six-year olds, the colossal crimson canine has not a prayer. Starring in a 2D film up against some of the CG monsters prowling the Oscar scene, even a pooch bigger than Clifford would be dwarfed.

The Legend of Buddha (500 - 1) Pentamedia Garphics Ltd. Just curious: What kind of stuff do they give away at the press junkets? This feature from India is an admirable effort but the (2D) animation I’ve been able to see is no better than that airing on, say, Toon Disney. Buddha saw very limited release and was virtually unseen in the United States. Never fear; the subcontinent that produced Bollywood is going to be a major player contending for Oscar, and soon.

Disney’s Teacher’s Pet (100 - 1) Walt Disney Pictures. This isn’t a bad little TV series, and the movie mainly follows suit. Its 2D animation at least has the virtue of not looking like anything else on all those other cable-based shows. There’s a plot that features genetic engineering (something you don’t typically see outside of anime) but novelty alone won’t put this film at the head of the class.

Home on the Range (75 - 1) Walt Disney Pictures. There is a goofy spirit to this flick, and its sprightly bovine heroines are fun to watch. The animation is mostly 2D and virtually spurts its udders at the CGI entries as if performing one last act of rebellion against going quietly into that good night. If the animation style were any flatter, you could slip this whole film under the door with room to spare. This a better film than its reviews indicated, but Disney’s 2D days are done and so are their hopes for one last Oscar as the inkwells dry up for good.

Sky Blue (50 - 1) Tin House Productions. If nothing else, this Korean entry directed by Moon Sang Kim certainly gives audiences their money’s worth. Cel animation, live action, miniatures and CG are all featured against the backdrop of a romantic triangle set in a devastated (is there any other kind?) future. South Korea is known as a destination for America’s runaway animation, but the country has been steadily developing its own genre known as manwha youngwha for quite some time and it’s no surprise that an Oscar contender has arisen at last. There are some nice ideas here (a city that actually runs on pollution). The animation includes every known medium, but this film is a depressing downer; too many of its dreary, post-apocalyptic statements and themes concerning oppression have been played out in countless other anime features to much better effect. Can’t anyone in Asia make an animated film in which humanity is not headed for a dark and violent future filled with nasty machines? This picture carries the alternate title, Wonderful Days, but it won’t see any come Oscar night.







Comments


tiIeIimb (not verified) | Mon, 08/29/2011 - 01:07 | Permalink
I think Wonderful days should of gotten better odds than Polar Express. I have a copy of Wonderful days and I'm still in awe of the animation done. I am also proud that something great came from my ancestral homeland. Don't get me wrong the Incredibles and Shrek 2 were both great series, but they fell into the trap of being kid friendly films. I think films like Wonderful Days and Ghost in the Shell set the bar of animation to a whole new level. Sure the story is a little complicated. I'd have make a film make me think rather not think about anything. I also think the oscars should expand the Animated feature to match the Live Action Nominations (5 films). Three is just too narrow. I really think the next generation of animated films will be in either Japan or Korea. I think now the Animation Studios are begining to take notice.
Brian Mah (not verified) | Thu, 12/23/2004 - 01:00 | Permalink
Emru: Good to hear from you! My statement does do somewhat of an injustice to the hordes of otaku who beg to differ. It would have been much more accurate to say "couldn't some Asian filmmaker have put up a film for nomination in which...." since both nominated films do indeed fit the category I described. Anime does in fact represent a wonderfully diverse panoply of styles. There are are many series that do not feature a dark and violent future populated by nasty machines, but there are a depressing number that do. (Come to think of it, we do the same thing in the U.S.) In my opinion, after the anime groundbreakers (and we fans know which films those are) there were a great many inferior derivations that were violent, hypersexual, and bloody seemingly for the sake of it. My hat is still off to both Sky Blue and GITS 2, which I find to be superior representatives of ther genre. I'd rather watch either one than sit through any given episode of Love Hina :)
Martin Goodman (not verified) | Tue, 12/21/2004 - 01:00 | Permalink
> Can’t anyone in Asia make an animated film in which humanity is not headed for a dark and violent future filled with nasty machines? Hmmm. Cowboy Bebop, Giant Robo, Macross, Crusher Joe, Dirty Pair. And I'm not even warmed up.
Emru Townsend (not verified) | Sun, 12/19/2004 - 01:00 | Permalink

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.